How to Set the Right Keyframe Interval for Streaming?

What is a keyframe interval?

The keyframe interval, often referred to as the I-frame interval, specifies the frequency at which full frames (keyframes or I-frames) are inserted into a video stream. Keyframes act as anchor points, containing a complete image of the scene, while subsequent frames, such as P-frames and B-frames, encode only the changes relative to previous frames to optimize compression. The keyframe interval has a significant impact on both encoding efficiency and streaming latency: shorter intervals increase bandwidth usage and file size due to more frequent I-frames, while longer intervals enhance compression but may lead to higher latency and slower recovery from playback disruptions. The ideal keyframe interval balances these factors to suit the specific requirements of the streaming application.

‍

‍

Importance of keyframe intervals

1. Video quality: The frequency of keyframes directly impacts the quality of the video stream. More frequent keyframes can lead to higher visual fidelity, particularly in dynamic scenes with rapid motion. Conversely, fewer keyframes may result in lower quality during fast transitions.
2. Bandwidth management: A shorter keyframe interval increases data transmission, which can strain bandwidth, especially for viewers with slower internet connections. On the other hand, longer intervals reduce bandwidth usage but may compromise video clarity and responsiveness.
3. User experience: Keyframes serve as reference points for seeking within a video. A shorter interval allows users to jump to different parts of the video more smoothly, enhancing the overall viewing experience.
4. Error resilience: In cases of packet loss during transmission, playback resumes at the next keyframe. Therefore,tighter intervals can help mitigate issues related to network fluctuations.

Setting keyframe intervals with FFmpeg

Use the following command to set the keyframe interval:

1ffmpeg -i input.mp4 -g <interval> output.mp4

Let’s take an example of how to set the keyframe interval with FFmpeg:

‍
For example, a keyframe interval of 2 seconds at 30 frames per second (fps) means a keyframe will be inserted every 60 frames.

1ffmpeg -i input.mp4 -g 60 output.mp4

In the above command ‘-g 60’ indicates that a keyframe will be created every 60 frames (2 seconds at 30 fps)

Using the ‘-force_key_frames’ option:

For more precise control over keyframe placement, especially when dealing with varying frame rates, you can use the -force_key_frames option. This allows you to specify exact time intervals for inserting keyframes.

1ffmpeg -i input.mp4 -force_key_frames "expr:gte(t,n_forced*2)" output.mp4

In the above command the expression expr:gte(t,n_forced*2) forces a keyframe to be inserted every 2 seconds

Setting keyframe intervals in OBS studio

Open Broadcaster Software (OBS) is one of the most widely used tools for live streaming. Here’s how to set your keyframe interval in OBS:

1. Open OBS studio: Launch the software on your computer.
2. Access settings: Click on "Settings" in the bottom-right corner.
3. Output settings: In the left sidebar select "Output" tab. In the "Output" section, choose your desired encoder (e.g., x264, NVENC, or AMD VCE) from the drop-down menu. Although different encoders may have slightly varying settings, the fundamental concept of keyframe interval remains consistent.
4. Find keyframe interval: Under the "Streaming" section, locate the "Keyframe Interval" option.
   • For x264 (CPU-based Encoder), set the keyframe interval to 2. If you encounter network issues or high-latency connections, you may want to adjust it to 1, though this could increase the bitrate requirement.
   • For NVENC (NVIDIA GPU-based Encoder), you can set the keyframe interval to 2 or leave it at "Default," as NVIDIA's encoder typically manages this effectively on its own.
   • For AMD VCE (AMD GPU-based Encoder), you can also set the keyframe interval to 2 or leave it at "Default," similar to NVENC.
5. Set your interval: Enter your desired value (in seconds). OBS allows settings from 1 to 60 seconds.
6. Apply changes: Click "Apply" and then "OK" to save your settings.

Recommended keyframe intervals

General recommendations

For most streaming scenarios, a keyframe interval of 2 seconds is commonly recommended. This setting strikes a balance between maintaining video quality and managing bandwidth effectively. However, specific use cases might require adjustments:

• Static scenes: For content such as news broadcasts or talk shows where scenes are stable, a 2-second interval is generally sufficient.
• Action-packed streams: For fast-paced content like sports or gaming, consider reducing the interval to 1 second. This allows for quicker updates to the stream, ensuring that viewers see every critical moment without lag.

Platform-specific guidelines

Different streaming platforms have unique requirements for keyframe intervals:

• YouTube live: Recommends a keyframe interval of 2 seconds.
• Twitch: Suggests intervals between 2 and 4 seconds, depending on the nature of the content.
• Facebook live: Generally, follows similar guidelines as YouTube.

Factors influencing the configuration of keyframe interval settings

When determining your keyframe interval, consider several factors:

1. Content type and complexity

The nature of your content plays a significant role in deciding on an appropriate keyframe interval:

• For high-motion content (like gaming or sports), a shorter keyframe interval (1 second) helps maintain clarity and detail.
• For slower-paced or static content, a longer interval (2-4 seconds) may suffice without sacrificing quality.

2. Available bandwidth

Your internet connection's bandwidth affects how you should configure your keyframe intervals:

• A lower keyframe interval demands more bandwidth due to increased data transmission.
• If bandwidth is limited, opting for a longer keyframe interval can help reduce buffering issues at the cost of some video quality.

3. The trade-offs of keyframe intervals

Setting an optimal keyframe interval involves balancing multiple factors:

• Quality vs bandwidth: Shorter intervals enhance quality but require higher bandwidth; longer intervals save on data but may introduce artifacts or lag.
• Latency considerations: In live streaming scenarios, latency is critical. A shorter keyframe interval can help minimize delays, providing a more responsive viewing experience.

4. Testing and fine-tuning your settings

After setting your initial keyframe interval, it's essential to test and adjust based on real-world performance:

• Conduct test streams: Stream with different intervals while monitoring video quality and viewer feedback.
• Analyze performance metrics: Look at buffering rates and viewer engagement to assess whether adjustments are needed.
• Iterate based on feedback: Fine-tune your settings based on viewer experiences and any technical issues encountered.

How does FastPix manage keyframe intervals for streaming?

FastPix role in managing keyframe intervals for livestreaming primarily revolves around optimizing video delivery, reducing latency, and ensuring a smooth streaming experience for viewers. Here’s a closer look at how FastPix handles the keyframe interval within its livestreaming infrastructure:

1. Content distribution and compatibility: Content Delivery Network (CDN) ensures efficient delivery of video content by distributing keyframes and inter-frames across its global edge servers. This setup helps maintain consistent playback and reduces buffering by caching keyframes closer to viewers.
2. Adaptive bitrate streaming: For adaptive bitrate streaming, keyframe intervals play a crucial role in seamlessly switching between quality levels based on the viewer’s internet connection. FastPix uses the specified keyframe interval to synchronize switching points across different video renditions, allowing smooth transitions without pauses or buffering, particularly in HLS or DASH streams.
3. Buffering and latency control: FastPix’s livestreaming setup uses the keyframe interval to regulate buffering and optimize latency. A short, consistent keyframe interval (typically 2 seconds) allows FastPix’s servers to quickly deliver frames to players, reducing latency, which is essential for interactive streaming.
4. Stream resilience: FastPix monitors the keyframe interval to detect irregularities or changes in the stream. By identifying issues like missing or inconsistent keyframes, FastPix can respond to potential quality drops or disruptions in the stream, providing error-handling mechanisms that maintain stream stability.
5. Encoding and transcoding recommendations: We recommend specific settings, like a 2-second keyframe interval, to align with its infrastructure for optimal performance. This ensures that videos are transmitted consistently and in sync across FastPix’s global network, minimizing playback issues.

FastPix’s support for the keyframe interval thus ensures compatibility, low-latency streaming, and an adaptable viewing experience by efficiently caching and delivering video content.

Advanced considerations for video engineers and developers

For video engineers and developers looking to optimize their streaming setups further, consider these advanced strategies:

Adaptive bitrate streaming (ABR):

If you are implementing adaptive bitrate streaming, ensure that your keyframe intervals align with ABR requirements. A consistent keyframe interval (typically 1 or 2 seconds) allows players to switch between different bitrates smoothly without disrupting playback.

Fixed GOP length:

Using a fixed group of pictures (GOP) length ensures that keyframes are consistently placed, which is essential for smooth transitions during ABR. A strict GOP length helps maintain predictable segment sizes and timing, facilitating better performance across different devices and network conditions.

Encoding settings optimization for optimal performance

• Adjust frame rates according to content type; higher frame rates are ideal for action-packed streams while lower rates can suffice for static scenes.
• Optimize audio bitrate based on content; sports events may require lower audio quality than talk shows or music performances.‍

Conclusion

Selecting the right keyframe interval is vital for optimizing video quality, file size, and streaming performance. It's important to consider the type of streaming (live or on-demand), along with the resolution and bitrate, when adjusting.

In summary:

• A general recommendation is to start with a 2-second keyframe interval for most content.
• Adjust to 1 second for dynamic scenes and consider longer intervals for static or slower-paced content.
• Regularly test and refine your settings based on performance metrics and viewer feedback.

By following these guidelines, you can ensure that your streams are not only visually appealing but also smooth and enjoyable for your audience.

At FastPix, we focus on optimizing video streaming by analyzing keyframe intervals, video compression techniques, and streaming requirements. By understanding how these factors interact, we help content creators improve video quality and streaming performance, ensuring a smoother and more engaging viewing experience for their audience.

Create your free account and sign up today!